For what my little ole opinions are worth, I hope to write some short posts over the next week outlining specific policy stances in which I disagree with Sen. Obama.
For starters, I disagree with his opposition to the Colombia Free Trade Agreement.
Free trade is part of innovation. It can’t be stopped. It can be delayed and stymied by government intervention, like propping up the auto industry to placate union bosses, or failing to put left wing guerrillas in their proper place.
Trade is dictated in part by the iron law of wages, which is why jobs move to where the cost of labor and the skill of the worker are in closest balance.
As I heard some economists discussing on a recent radio show, free trade pulls those in advanced consumer economies into higher tech manufacturing and skilled service jobs. It pushes the lower skilled jobs to where the wages are lowest.
Thus, those in advanced economies are required to innovate in order to maintain their state of being “advanced”
It’s not a painless process. As the progeny of working class generations before me, I know well about the pain of downsizing and worker displacement. But the mettle of a society is how it reacts to challenges. We’ve never been a people that cotton to stagnation.
Holding up a free trade agreement with our top ally in that area in deference to placating union bosses is pretty short sighted. I guess it plays well to a certain Democratic demographic.
Here’s how one former NYT reporter, now a prof at Harvard, viewed the situation:
“All sides agree that the killings are dramatically down, and no one accuses the government of orchestrating them. By the unions’ own count, the killings dropped from a high of 275 in 1996 to 39 last year. The government says 26.
The assumption by the Democrats is that all were killed for union organizing. It is an assumption implied in reports they cite from groups such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. Those groups, however, rely on Colombian unions for their numbers, instead of collecting their own. The number of convictions now being won in the union’s own cases reveals that perhaps one-fifth, and almost certainly less than half, of the killings had to do with unionism.“
Filed under: International, National , bad policy, Barack Obama, Colombia Free Trade Agreement
Talking about it